Stonehenge Villas and The Villages at Arbor Chase are separate entries on the West Lafayette map. Their sales should also be kept separate from Stonehenge and Arbor Chase when researching a home.
Keeping the neighborhood records separate
Between October 2024 and October 2026, 19 homes in Stonehenge Villas closed at a median of $409,000, and 8 in The Villages at Arbor Chase closed at a median of $389,000. The typical house was 1,953 square feet in Stonehenge Villas and 2,002 in The Villages at Arbor Chase.
Stonehenge Villas
- Closed sales: 19
- Median sale: $409,000
- Range: $359,900 to $552,118
- Typical size: 1,953 square feet
- Built: 2019 to 2026
- Built in 2024 or later: 18 of the 19
The West Lafayette map tags it as mostly new construction, reflecting the recorded build years; the transaction history needs to establish the type of sale. The map shows a dash for homes here. The map explains a dash this way: the county's plat does not line up with the MLS neighborhood name, so the homes are not counted.
Without that count there is no selling pace, and this note does not guess at one. Stonehenge, a separate neighborhood on the map, is not included in these figures.
The Villages at Arbor Chase
- Closed sales: 8
- Median sale: $389,000
- Range: $360,000 to $499,500
- Typical size: 2,002 square feet
- Built: 2006 to 2013
- Built in 2024 or later: none
- Homes on the plat: 117, by Tippecanoe County parcel records
The map sets 8 sales against 117 homes and puts it at about one home in 29 selling each year. The two counts come from different records, the MLS and the county, so treat that as a rough figure. Arbor Chase, a separate neighborhood on the map, is not included in these figures.
One small sample, said plainly
Nineteen sales provide a larger sample in Stonehenge Villas, with most involving homes built recently. The individual records still need review before they are described as first builder sales or used to price a resale.
What the map does not tell you
The map does not record how many floors a house has, where the primary bedroom is, or who mows the lawn. Neither does this note. Villas and Villages are part of these neighborhoods' names, not a description of their floor plans. If a first-floor primary bedroom or no stairs is the reason you are looking, that is checked house by house, from the listing and the plan, before we tour.
Check the floor plan before treating the neighborhood name as evidence of one-level living.
For the owner thinking of selling
In Stonehenge Villas, most of the sales on record were homes the map classifies as new construction. An owner selling there is priced against those, and against the few older homes that sold. In The Villages at Arbor Chase the map classifies none of the sales as new construction, so an owner is priced against other homes of the same age.
In both, a price for one house is set against the sales that look most like it, not against the median.
What an association covers and what it costs is in its own documents, and I read them with you rather than summarize them from memory. Whether a move makes sense for your taxes is a question for your CPA.
Both neighborhoods are on the West Lafayette neighborhood map, each on its own terms, and the West Lafayette page covers the town.
Source: Indiana Regional MLS closed sales via Redfin, October 2024 through October 2026, single-family, condo and townhome, as compiled for the West Lafayette neighborhood map. Homes on the plat: Tippecanoe County parcel records, October 2026.
This note is general. It is not an appraisal, and it is not tax or legal advice. What a specific house would bring depends on that house.