Stonehenge has a substantial completed-sales record, including recently built homes alongside established properties. The neighborhood's total is useful context, while a resale analysis needs to identify transactions that match the particular house.
Stonehenge's completed sales
Between October 2024 and October 2026, 48 homes in Stonehenge closed at a median of $422,500. The typical house was 2,254 square feet.
Prices ran from $299,900 to $678,742, and the houses were built anywhere from 2000 to 2026. Twenty three of the 48 were new construction, so 25 were resales.
The neighborhood, as the map prints it
- Closed sales: 48
- Median sale: $422,500
- Range: $299,900 to $678,742
- Typical size: 2,254 square feet
- Built: 2000 to 2026
- New construction: 23 of the 48
- Homes for sale when the map was last read: 3
Those three listings were priced at $399,000, $418,000 and $420,000, between 2,050 and 3,263 square feet. That is a snapshot from the date in the source line below, not a live count.
What the 48 is and is not
It is the largest sales count of the 51 ranked neighborhoods on the West Lafayette map, out of 812 closed sales in all. It is not a verdict on the other 50. A neighborhood climbs that column by having a lot of houses, by having a builder delivering new ones, or by both, and Stonehenge has both: it is one of 11 neighborhoods on the map with any new construction at all, and those 11 neighborhoods carry the map's 148 new construction sales between them.
By build year, the map counts 23 of the 48 sales as new construction and the other 25 as older homes. Check the underlying sale history before relying on that distinction, since recorded build years alone do not establish the type of seller.
What that does to a resale here
It is good news and it comes with a caveat. The good news is depth: 25 resales in two years, in one subdivision, is a thick record. An appraiser has recent matched sales a few streets over, and a buyer's agent reading your price has somewhere to read it from.
Most sellers in most neighborhoods do not get that.
The caveat is that the median, the range and the typical size on that neighborhood are built from all 48 sales, new and resale together, and the map does not split them. A new house and a 2003 house in the same subdivision are not priced off the same sheet. So $422,500 is the right number for the neighborhood and the wrong number to carry into a listing conversation about a specific house without separating out which sales actually resemble it.
Who this suits
The built range runs from 2000 to 2026, which is the practical point for anyone choosing between new and established here: both exist inside one subdivision, at sizes that overlap. For an owner in the older part of Stonehenge thinking about one level living or a smaller house, the names are worth keeping straight. Stonehenge Villas is a separate neighborhood on the map with its own 19 sales, almost all of it new, and nothing in the figures above includes it.
The note on what sells in Stonehenge Villas and The Villages at Arbor Chase covers that neighborhood on its own.
For a 2004 resale, separate the 25 sales described as resales from the full count of 48, and verify the transaction classification before using either set. The headline count alone does not establish demand for that house.
What your house is worth, which of those sales an appraiser would accept, and what the new homes nearby will be priced at next spring are not in this neighborhood. Valuation of a specific property is its own piece of work and a lender's appraisal is the appraiser's. I will tell you which of the 25 resales your house is actually comparable to and where the record thins out.
The West Lafayette neighborhood map carries every neighborhood and column behind this note, the note on how to read that map explains the other columns, and the West Lafayette page sets out the town.
Source: 812 closed sales from the Indiana Regional MLS (via Redfin), Oct 2024 through Oct 2026, single-family, condo and townhome, as carried on the West Lafayette neighborhood map, read October 10, 2026 from map data as of October 5, 2026. Neighborhoods need at least five sales to be ranked. New construction counts and the homes for sale are the map's own. No individual sale addresses are used.
This note is general. It is not an appraisal. What a specific house would bring depends on that house.